Wednesday, June 22, 2011

Book Review: The Fight of Our Lives:

The Fight of Our Lives: Knowing the Enemy, Speaking the Truth & Choosing to Win the War against Radical Islam.

William Bennet and Seth Leibsohn (Thomas Nelson, Nashville, 2011)

***** (2 out of 5)

Sometimes you read a book, and it rankles and annoys you, but causes you to grow through the process. Sometimes you read a book and it makes your heart leap as you discover some great new truth. Sometimes you read a book and you think, “That is exactly what I’ve always thought, but never knew how to say!” Sometimes you read a book and it makes an indelible mark on your consciousness and forever changes the way you look at yourself and the world you inhabit. Unfortunately, “The Fight of our Lives” by conservative talk-show host William Bennett and co-author Seth Leibsohn is not a book that will produce any of these results. Actually I take that back – it may annoy and rankle you, but it is doubtful if you will grow through the interaction. This is the sort of book that you finish reading and ask, “Why did the authors write this book?”

I’m not a flaming liberal or a Muslim apologist who simply disagrees with the concept of targeting Radical Islam. Just the opposite – I think this book attempts to address a serious issue facing western society. Unfortunately, it does so in a way that makes it a completely superfluous read for anyone, regardless of where they stand on the issue. This is because those who are inclined to disagree with the book’s premise, it is unnecessarily inflammatory and rhetorical, and for those inclined to agree with the premise, it provides nothing more than a lengthy “Rah Rah Rah”. There is very little in the way of any real discussion about the motives and theological beliefs of these men. Yes, there is plenty discussion of the fact that radical Muslims want to kill people (or Americans specifically, according to the book), but not a lot of discussion given to the historical, social, and theological threads that make Islam what it is. Understanding is the key to defeating radical Islam, not straw men and sensationalism.

The book also completely assumes the righteousness of the United States on the world stage, as though the United States has no questions to ask, or examinations to make – they simply need to stand up for themselves. Now, do not get me wrong – I’m not saying the Islamists are somehow justified in their actions. Unfortunately, in our current age, the major players cannot simply be divided into “good guys” and “bad guys” the way this book portrays it. It takes a laughably naive view of the world today and it's credibility suffers greatly as a result.

I usually give long, relatively detailed reviews. This book doesn’t warrant one, in my opinion. If you are a progressive or Muslim person, this book will only annoy you. If you are a conservative person, this book will only help you become a prejudiced, inflammatory person who can only talk to other conservatives. This book adds very little, if anything at all, to an understanding of the place of Islam in our world today. Skip this book, unless you would enjoy reading an extended talk show monologue.

LegalStuff: I received this book free from the publisher through the BookSneeze.com book review bloggers program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own.