I was in my early teens when Bruce Wilkinson’s little book ‘The Prayer of Jabez’ swept through the land of evangelicalism. In fact, it spread beyond evangelicalism and was at the top of the New York Times bestseller list and sold 9 million copies. I actually read the book and attended a conference where Wilkinson was speaking, and for a while I dutifully prayed the Prayer of Jabez along with, it seemed, half the world. I fully admit I didn’t really understand the principle behind the book very well and treated it as somewhat of a magic spell. Not surprisingly, it didn’t really change my life and I moved on. The next year at the same conference Wilkinson was on to his next new revolutionary idea (the Power of the Vine, I believe), and I tried that for a while as well. Like the prayer of Jabez, my enthusiasm petered off again.
So ten years later, with a more mature theology and interest in spiritual matters, I was interested to review his book “You were Born for This: 7 Keys to a life of Predictable Miracles.” Wilkinson's basic premise in this book is that by being sensitive to God's promptings, one can become a regular miracle 'delivery person' for God.
So first, the good aspects of this book. One thing that I recall with the Prayer of Jabez is that many felt it encouraged a self-centered, introspective practice of Christianity. I was worried that this book would focus on creating 'miracles for yourself', but was pleased to find that the focus was squarely on serving others; not on creating self-serving miracles, but on being a minister for God for the benefit of others. This was an unexected surprise because I had expected something of a Prayer of Jabez redux.
Wilkinson also obviously has a heart for people and a developed skill of reading their life situations and of speaking wisdom in their lives. He seems quite genuine, and his concern for the cares and concerns of complete strangers convicted me at times, as I tend to be a reclusive introvert.
Now, for the bad. The first issue is that Wilkinson absolutely mangles the meaning of the word, 'miracle'. The miracles in the New Testament are supernatural occurrences that have no natural explanation. Miracles are very important in the Gospels and Acts, as they serve to vindicate the identity of Jesus and the message of the Apostles. What was humurous to me was that many of Wilkinson’s ‘miracles’ happened when he or someone else gave a tip to someone in the service industry and ‘miraculously’ that person had a pressing financial need. Walking on water is a miracle; the fact that a waiter has outstanding financial needs is a no-brainer. I’m not trying to deny that God meets these needs in amazing ways or that Wilkinson is wrong to seek to be the means by which God fulfils these needs. However, to call this provision ‘miraculous’ is to introduce confusion and to minimize truly supernatural workings of God.
While the biography on the back of this book refers to Wilkinson as "one of the world's best-known Bible teachers", this book is non-biblical at best. This is not to say it is entirely anti-biblical or 'heretical'. It has myriads of anecdotes and lists of principles, but very little Scripture. What Scripture is included is usually simply referenced rather than exegeted, and there were numerous examples of out-of-context quotations. I'm not one of those people who say that unless a book has 'X' amount of Scripture it can't be good; however, when a Christian leader claims to have life-changing information about the life-purpose of each Christian, we need to expect their teaching to be firmly rooted in Scripture.
The above point leads me to what I think is a more harmful aspect of Wilkinson’s book. Wilkinson expects Christians to operate on the basis of ‘prompts’ and ‘bumps’ in order to be effective ‘miracle bringers’. Scripture does not talk about ‘promptings’ as the precursor of good works of compassion – instead, Christians are to devote themselves to developing discernment and a compassionate attitude to those in need. (cf. Titus 3:8; 1 Tim 6:18; Heb 10:24). While the difference may at first seem small – in the end people in need are cared for - this is actually not necessarily the case. What about those for whom one does not feel a prompting? James does not say, “If one of you sees your brother without food and clothes, and you feel a prompting, meet their needs.” No, he says that it is the Christian’s obligation to meet the needs of his brother – end of story (Jas 2:14-16). What Wilkinson would like to describe as miraculous and supernatural, the Bible describes as normal and everyday. The Church needs to recover this ‘eagerness for good works’. Christians need to be taught to be sensitive and aware to the needs of those around them and respond, rather than relying on undefined and subjective ‘bumps’.
The other issue I have with this book is that Wilkinson’s discussion of ‘miracle’ working takes place in a theological vacuum. Wilkinson’s discussion in the book rarely touches on the wider purpose of God for his Church, or his plan of salvation through the ages. One gets the impression that what God is on about in the world is making sure people have their needs met. This is important, but without a theological basis for our compassion and care, the Church has been reduced to the Red Cross or Rotary Club. We are to be compassionate and caring as the result of the Gospel, and Wilkinson completely glosses over this.
This book is not a ‘dangerous’ book, I just do not think it is a very helpful book. Like many of Wilkinson’s other books, it is very faddish and marketed as the ‘secret’ to a successful Christian life. Unfortunately, it is not grounded in a deep understanding of the gospel, which must be the foundation for any type of ‘radical’ Christianity. A book which has all the good points of Wilkinson’s book, as well as the missing theological basis and none of the sketchy exegesis, is David Platt’s book, “Radical”. Your time would be much better spent reading that book than this one. In the end, “You Were Born for This” is too formulaic and theologically vacuous. The emphasis on helping others is good, but the methods that Wilkinson suggests are unbiblical and potentially harmful.
LegalStuff: I received this book free from the Multnomah Press book review bloggers program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own.